Jayy:
You've got your secrets locked inside, You've got them hidden so well
I'm gonna break down all your walls and find out what you won't tell
I know you think you coined the slogan of the master disguise
Let's cut right through it to the bullshit, I see all of your lies

Dahvie:
I dropped my guard
You played your cards
You dug a hole in my skin
You cut me deep
Then watched me bleed
While you claimed your innocence
It's in your eyes
Your filthy lies
The truth is there on your face
So keep in mind
That I'm not blind
My memories can't be erased

Chorus:

Jayy:
Took your love
And wasted
All of it
On someone
Who could care
Less for you
I kept my word
Everything I said
Came directly from my heart it's true

Dahvie:
Don't think I won't forget
The things you've done
Don't think you won't regret
Forbidding fun
I've drawn my line with you
In the sand
Right now you are the one
Who's unforgiven

Jayy:
UNFORGIVEN!
UNFORGIVEN!

Dahvie:
You walked me to the gates of Heaven now I'm burning in Hell
Took something pure and true and turned it into something to sell
Can you live with yourself each time you think about what you've done
This is about the game you play, not the game that you won

Jayy:
You think you're slick
But here's the trick
I'll always know more than you know
You choose your fate
This masquerade
Is done when you walk out the door
Don't justify
Your bullshit lies
When it's obvious that you're fake
Who's fooling who
I know the truth
This drama's more than I can take

Took your love
And wasted
All of it
On someone
Who could care
Less for you
I kept my word
Everything I said
Came directly from my heart it's true

Dahvie:
Don't think I won't forget
The things you've done
Don't think you won't regret
Forbidding fun
I've drawn my line with you
In the sand
Right now you are the one
Who's unforgiven

Bridge:

Jayy:
You had your fun
With all that was forbidden
You are the one
Who is unforgiven

Dahvie:
GO!

Jayy:
Took your love
And wasted
All of it
On someone
Who could care
Less for you
I kept my word
Everything I said
Came directly from my heart it's true

Dahvie:
Let go, just let go
You'll be fine on your own
Let go, just let go
You'll be fine on your own

Jayy:
UNFORGIVEN!
UNFORGIVEN!